Selective Coordination Definition
Selective coordination is the intended arrangement of protective devices so that, for a fault, the device nearest the affected circuit operates while upstream devices remain closed when practicable. The goal is to limit the interruption to the smallest portion of an electrical system that can be isolated safely. For example, a branch-circuit fault should not unnecessarily interrupt unrelated feeders or the incoming supply. This outcome depends on the actual devices, fault conditions, and system configuration; it is not guaranteed simply by choosing breakers from one product family.
For new switchgear, the definition becomes a design objective that must be evaluated across connected protective devices. The project team needs to identify which loads require continuity, where faults may occur, and what interruption is acceptable. Selectivity does not replace proper fault protection or safe equipment application. Qualified electrical professionals must review the system design and applicable requirements for the project.
How Protective Devices Work Together
A protective device responds to current and time characteristics established by its design and settings. Coordination analysis compares those characteristics for devices in series, such as a downstream branch breaker, an upstream feeder device, and an incoming protective device. If their operating regions overlap under a relevant fault condition, more than one device may trip. If they are separated appropriately for the assessed conditions, the downstream device may clear the fault without opening the upstream device.
The result depends on more than nominal device ratings. Device type, trip-unit functions, adjustable settings, current-limiting behavior, and the available fault current at each location can affect the relationship. Manufacturers’ published coordination information may apply only to defined device combinations and conditions. A designer should verify the exact proposed combinations rather than infer performance from frame size, product labels, or a general statement that equipment is coordinated.
Project Inputs That Shape the Analysis
A useful coordination study starts with a current one-line diagram and a clear account of the power system. Relevant inputs can include the source and transformer data, conductor lengths and sizes, grounding arrangement, protective devices already in place, and expected operating configurations. The study also needs project-specific fault-current information or the data required to calculate it. Normal and alternate sources, ties, generators, and other operating modes can change current levels and device relationships.
Load priorities and applicable design requirements also matter. The team should identify essential or critical circuits, desired outage boundaries, and any required response to faults, while recognizing that coordination must not compromise protection. Information for existing upstream devices may be necessary even when the new switchgear is the procurement focus. Missing or assumed data should be identified explicitly so the responsible engineer can decide whether it is adequate or needs confirmation.
Design Choices and Equipment Interfaces
Selective coordination is determined across the connected system, not within a switchboard or switchgear lineup in isolation. New equipment must interface with upstream utility or facility protection, downstream distribution devices, and any alternate-source equipment included in the design. The designer may need to select device types, trip functions, setting ranges, or equipment arrangements that support the coordination objective while also meeting fault-protection and equipment-application requirements.
For custom new switchgear, provide the manufacturer with approved project documents and clearly identify required device functions, interfaces, and coordination constraints. Confirm which devices are part of the assembly and which are furnished or controlled by others. UL 891 applies to suitable switchboard assemblies where applicable; it does not establish selective coordination by itself or automatically apply to every switchgear product. Applicable standards and assembly requirements depend on the design and project and should be verified.
Study, Settings, and Verification
Coordination is commonly evaluated using protective-device time-current information alongside short-circuit and other required system analyses. The qualified designer should document the devices reviewed, system assumptions, operating modes, and any areas where selectivity cannot be established. For equipment with adjustable protection, the proposed settings need to be checked against the study and the device manufacturer’s limits. A setting should not be changed in the field based only on a general preference for continuity.
Before procurement is finalized, reconcile the study with the equipment submittal and the project’s control and protection requirements. After installation, qualified personnel can verify device identities and settings against approved documents using project procedures and applicable requirements. Testing or commissioning scope should be defined by the responsible project team; no generic test proves coordination for every possible fault. Changes to sources, devices, settings, or system configuration may require renewed engineering review.
Practical Next Steps for New Switchgear
To move from a coordination objective to a buildable specification, assemble the current one-line diagram, available source and fault data, device schedules, and the latest coordination study if one exists. Mark the boundaries where continued service matters and list any upstream or downstream devices outside the new equipment scope. Ask the engineer of record to identify required functions, settings responsibility, study deliverables, and any unresolved assumptions before the manufacturer prepares a project-specific design.
During review, compare the proposed equipment configuration and device data with the approved study, then route discrepancies to the responsible engineer rather than treating them as procurement substitutions. For a Central Texas project or another US location, coordinate document revisions, submittal timing, and shipment requirements with the project schedule; custom assemblies are built to specification, and lead time depends on the project. This process helps keep the new equipment aligned with the intended fault-isolation plan without promising an unverified coordination result.
Project specification checklist
Use this checklist to organize the details for a project-specific review. Final ratings, applicable standards and equipment selections depend on the approved design.
| Item | What to confirm |
|---|---|
| System diagram | Confirm the current one-line diagram, normal and alternate configurations, and the boundary of the study. |
| Source and fault data | Provide verified source, transformer, and fault-current information or identify assumptions for engineering review. |
| Protective-device scope | List upstream, new, and downstream devices, including device data and who supplies or controls each. |
| Continuity objectives | Identify circuits that should remain in service when practicable and define intended fault-isolation boundaries. |
| Settings and verification | Confirm who prepares and approves settings, study updates, and any project-specific testing or commissioning. |